When God rains bread from heaven

Two Sundays ago, we heard about the Passover and the Israelites’ desperate flight from Egypt.  In the meantime, the Israelites have crossed the Red Sea, and today they find themselves wandering in the Sinai wilderness.  Like so many who start out on a new endeavor with a rush of excitement, their adrenaline has waned, and the magnitude of what the Israelites have done by fleeing Pharoah hits them like a wave.  At least in Egypt they were housed and fed.  Now, they are exposed and hungry, frantic and afraid.  An ambient anxiety pervades them.  The Israelites do what people do in such circumstances, then and now: They cry out, complain, murmur in furtive desperation because they don’t know what else to do.  The Israelites are hungry, in every way.

And then one morning, Exodus tells us, “There was a layer of dew around the camp.  When the layer of dew lifted, there on the surface of the wilderness was a fine flaky substance, as fine as frost on the ground.  When the Israelites saw it, they said to one another, ‘Man hu?’  For they did not know what it was.”

What is it?

Man hu.  That’s Hebrew for “What is it?”  And that’s what they call this miraculous stuff: What is it?—Man hu—manna.  All the Israelites know is that it is sweet and edible, and they aren’t hungry anymore.

As with so many other stories in the bible, we quickly become preoccupied with its factual details at the risk of losing its meaning: Where did Cain’s and Abel’s wives come from?  Where did Noah’s Ark hit land?  How did Jonah survive in the belly of that fish for three days?  And similarly, we ask Man hu?  What is manna?

The twentieth century entomologist F.S. Bodenheimer posed a hypothesis.  Bodenheimer said the most plausible explanation is that manna was “the sweet secretion of desert aphids that live on tamarisk trees in the region.  The aphids exude the excess sugar they obtain from the trees in the form of droplets that, when dried in the desert air, become flaky sweet crystals.”[i] (Mmm…delicious.)

If that nugget of information is the important thing in this story for you, go with it.  But lest we forget, the Israelites were probably the engineers who built Pharoah’s pyramids.  They were not primitive people of childish understanding.  And yet, the nature of the manna was not what was important to them.  They were content to call this food that rained from heaven “What is it?” because what was important to them was not its organic properties.  What was important to them was that, when they were in such deep need that they knew only apprehension, confusion, and anxiety, God rained bread from heaven.

We understand that intuitively, I think.  We know it in our own lives.  When we are lost in life’s wilderness, some signpost suddenly appears that points us in a new direction.  When we are floundering, a hand as from nowhere reaches out to steady us.  When we are overwhelmed by anxiety, a phone call or the direct gaze of a friend catches us, and for a moment the anxiety melts.  Sometimes these saving graces come through human mediation.  Other times, we experience them directly from God.  Pause here and think specifically of an instance in your life when this has happened, when were you in need—great or small, persistent or passing—and God provided something or someone to sustain you.  Like wispy flakes of manna, by themselves and to an outside observer, each of these instances is insubstantial, ephemeral, maybe even unnoticeable.  But to those of us who have experienced them, we know that they can feed a starving soul.  We know that they are bread from heaven.

I’ll share one such instance from my own life.  I’ll say at the outset that I don’t understand it any more than we can understand manna.  (Professor Bodenheimer notwithstanding.)  I had not yet received my cancer diagnosis, and the near-crippling issues with my back had not yet emerged.  It was the summer of 2019, and something in life felt off, like when a tire is ten pounds under-inflated, or when music is a half-note flat.  I couldn’t put my finger on it, but I walked through my days with an increasing sense of foreboding.  Familiar landscapes took on the look of wilderness.  Do you understand what I’m talking about?  Can you relate in your own life?

And then, one weekday morning I was driving down Waugh Blvd., about to turn right onto Memorial Drive to head into downtown Houston.  John Denver’s song “Rocky Mountain High” was playing on Spotify.  Denver sang the line, “I’ve seen it raining fire in the sky,” and the world was suddenly…different.  For a few moments, the veil dropped.  The wilderness scattered, and the concrete urban jungle was infused by God.  I don’t know how else to say it.  (Trust me, I’ve tried.)  By the time I reached the Cathedral, the veil was back in place.  The world had resumed its usual character.  But bread had rained down from heaven.  The gift of grace had been given.  I could not have known what challenges were coming in my life any more than the Israelites could have conceived of what was coming in theirs, but God gave me manna when I needed it, and I thank God that God did.

What do we do with that?  That’s the question, isn’t it?    When the manna appears for us, unexpected and undeserved, how do we respond?  Today we launch our fall Stewardship Campaign, and our Stewardship Council has selected as this year’s theme St. Peter’s counsel in response to that very question.  How do we respond to God’s gift of manna from heaven?  St. Peter says, “Use whatever gift you have received to serve others, as faithful stewards of God’s grace in its various forms.”[ii]        

We scarcely need Peter’s instruction, because the impulse to be stewards is actually part of the gift.  When God sends us a sign, we want to point others to it.  When God throws us a lifeline, we want to cast it further.  When God rains bread from heaven, we want to feed others.

Stewardship is not about guilt.  It’s not about duty.  It’s not, ultimately, even about the material needs of the church (as important as those are).  Stewardship is about the joy of acknowledging God’s gift to us of manna, and then sharing those gifts so that others may be fed.

We receive and share the infinite variety of God’s grace through our worship, our friendly fellowship, our sweaty service, our ardent prayer and faithful teaching.  And, undoubtedly and with equal joy, we pass along God’s grace through our financial commitment to the church.

For the next six weeks, this is our faithful work.  Pledge packets were mailed out this past week, and they include a booklet that shares with detailed transparency Saint Mark’s financial needs for 2024.  Our ministry budgets have not received increases in years; we have deferred maintenance needs on our campus; inflation has ratcheted up our fixed costs just to keep the lights on.  Funding these things could seem burdensome, except that we have received God’s grace as manna from heaven, and sharing God’s grace is our response in joy!

This year your Stewardship Council and Vestry are asking that parishioners who have not pledged in the past make a financial pledge to the parish as your response to God’s manna.  For returning pledgers, we are asked to consider a Matthias Gift in addition to a regular pledge.  The Matthias Gift is named after Matthias, the 13th Apostle who was added to the original Twelve.  The Matthias Gift is a “13th payment” on a twelve-month pledge.  Our stewardship material explain how this works, and I encourage you to read it with care.  If we increase our pledge base by 10% and our returning pledgers stretch to make a Matthias Gift in addition to their pledge, then we will meet our budget goal for the ministry of this amazing place in 2024.

In joy, I report to you that Jill and I have already pledged and committed to a Matthias Gift for 2024.  With even greater joy, I report that 100% of our Vestry have also already pledged for 2024.  That’s remarkable leadership and hopefully is both inspiration and aspiration for all our parishioners.   How do we make sense of God’s grace, God’s manna?  What is it, exactly, we ask as the Israelites asked.  It is mysterious and inexplicable.  But we know, and we commit to share, that it is bread from heaven.  


[i] Kass, Leon R. Founding God’s Nation: Reading Exodus, pg. 228.

[ii] 1 Peter 4:10

When God Acts

Last week Michael McCain and I were discussing upcoming holy days on the calendar and how we should best prepare for them.  After that conversation, I later realized we missed a most important date.  The holy day in question is November 18, as sacred around these parts as any date other than Christmas or Easter…What is it?  It is, of course, the opening day of duck season in Arkansas!

Thinking about that made me recall fondly the duck hunting I did during my ten-year sojourn in Texas, usually with my friend and parishioner Neil Giles.  Neil belongs to the St. Charles Bay hunting and fishing club on the Texas coast near Corpus Christi.  Neil and I would drive down on a Friday afternoon, watch the sunset on the bay, and stay in one of the club’s cabins.  Promptly at 4:00 a.m., someone would pound on the cabin door to awaken us, and after sleepily donning our chest waders, we’d stumble to the dining hall, where we’d be plied with a heavy breakfast of pork chops, biscuits and gravy, and coffee as thick as tar.  The first time I went hunting with Neil, I couldn’t understand why they served such a large breakfast at zero-dark-thirty.

After eating we’d get into an Everglades-style airboat and travel at breakneck speed through the salt marshes of the bay with only a spotlight to guide the way.  The experience was surreal, and though we were there by choice, the sensation was as if we were fleeing from someone or something. 

It took a long time to reach the duck blinds that rose up out of the bay like tiny islands.  The airboat would leave us there, still almost an hour before dawn, and the boat sometimes wouldn’t return until almost midday.  It didn’t take long to figure out why we’d been encouraged to eat so much food.  It was necessary sustenance for the journey ahead.      

That takes us to the Exodus reading today: The institution among the ancient Israelites of the Passover meal.  Anyone who has ever been privileged to attend a seder meal with Jewish friends will recollect this passage.  It is God’s careful and deliberate instruction for how to prepare the Passover lamb for the feast.  God says, “[The] lamb shall be without blemish, a year-old male…they shall eat it roasted over the fire with unleavened bread and bitter herbs. Do not eat any of it raw or boiled in water, but roasted over the fire, with its head, legs, and inner organs.”

But the modern Passover Seder meal, at least for Christian guests observing the ritual, risks leaving the impression of the comfort food of my hunting breakfasts, or the Thanksgiving meal of a Norman Rockwell painting.  God’s next instruction blows such images out of the water.  Crucially, God tells the Israelites what to do with a bit of the lamb’s blood.  God says, “Take some of the blood and put it on the two doorposts…of the houses in which they eat it…For I will pass through the land of Egypt…and I will strike down every firstborn in the land… when I see the blood, I will pass over you, and no plague shall destroy you when I strike the land of Egypt.”

Now we see that this is no ordinary meal at all.  It portends something momentous and ominous.  Coincident with this meal, something terrible will happen in Egypt, where the Israelites presently live as abused and enslaved people.  There will be a crescendo of turmoil, and it will spell either the destruction or liberation for the Israelites.  It is only then that we begin to understand what this whole meal is about.  Listen to the bits I’ve previously leapfrogged:

God says, “You shall keep [the lamb] until the fourteenth day of this month…You shall eat it with unleavened bread…You shall let none of it remain until the morning…This is how you shall eat it: [with] your loins girded, your sandals on your feet, and your staff in your hand; and you shall eat it hurriedly.”

What is God saying here?  In a lunar calendar, the fourteenth day of the month is the night of the full moon, where travel by night is most feasible.  Unleavened bread doesn’t need time to rise; it can be prepared and cooked quickly.  Girded loins and sandaled feet mean you eat—and sleep—with your clothes on, and with your protective staff at the ready.  And finally, God says, in essence, “Hurry!” 

Do you see what all this means?  God is not playing the part of Julia Child or Rachael Ray, giving God’s people a recipe for a lovely lamb.  There is no sitting back after supper and loosening one’s belt.  There’s no time for dessert.  God is preparing God’s captive people to make a run for it, to flee to liberation and safety.  God is prompting them, instructing them, and most importantly, making sure they have food to sustain them for the journey.

What we don’t get in today’s passage are the eleven chapters of Exodus leading up to this one, chapters in which the Israelites are consistently paralyzed from acting.  They have no agency; they have lost the ability to imagine a life in which they are not held captive; they take no initiative to reclaim their integrity and gain their freedom.  But now, through the Passover, God has both empowered and energized the Israelites. Because God has prompted them, because God has instructed them, because God has provided sustenance for their journey, the Israelites find the strength to move.      

As always with Holy Scripture, we are left to wonder and ask: Is this just an old story, memorializing what God once did, or is it somehow more?  Does it in any way inform our own lives in the present?  For our Jewish siblings, the answer is yes.  When they retell the Passover story each year, they use first rather than third person pronouns.  The Ashkenazi Haggadah used at the seder says, “In every generation, we are obligated to see ourselves as though we personally came out of Egypt.”[i]  Observant Jews imagine that, just as God acted in and for the Israelites of old, God’s action is operative in their own lives, here and now.

What about us?  The great Church Father St. Gregory of Nyssa taught seventeen hundred years ago[ii] that, as people of the New Covenant, it is right and good for us, too, to imagine how the Exodus story also speaks to us, here and now.  The Passover story encourages us to ask: In what ways—either in your external circumstances or your internal soul—are you held captive by something in your life that has stripped you of your agency, that threatens your well-being, from which you feel too weak to escape?  In what ways do you feel paralyzed and unable, not only to escape to freedom, but even to make the very first, very small move in freedom’s direction?

The Passover promise is that God will make the first move.  When we cannot conceive of a way forward, God will present a way.  When we cannot conceive how to prepare, God will prepare us, sometimes without our even realizing it.  When we cannot find the will to lift our feet to take the first step, God will act.         

Unfortunately, strains of bad Christian theology—and internet memes like those footprints on the beach—sometimes claim this means God will whisk us easily away from distress.  It is not so.  We are not toddlers, and God will not pick us up and carry us on the divine hip.  What does God do?  God prompts; God instructs; God empowers; and, most importantly, God provides us spiritual food that strengthens us for the journey.  God shows us paths to travel where before we only saw trees.[iii]  God girds us with spiritual clothing and staff when we thought our souls were naked and exposed.  God grants us holy food through the Eucharist, through prayer, through communion with one another.  Like the doorposts of the Israelites, God marks us as God’s own, and if we will heed God’s prompting and follow where God calls, seas will part, and we will enter new life.


[i] https://www.haggadot.com/clip/avadim-hayinu-we-were-slaves-egypt

[ii] See St. Gregory of Nyssa’s classic text The Life of Moses.

[iii] See the wonderful allusion at Mark 8:24.